Oct 17th 2013, 15:32:02
The amusing thing is that everyone fluffed about land-trading several years back and nothing was done.
Then everyone just accepted it, and even NBK, who was the biggest opponent of land-trading, now is okay with it.
Now they actually keep messing with the formulas to make land-trading less lucrative.
Regardless though, the only way land-trading is going to be taken out of the game is if the game mechanics make it less lucrative than other methods of gaining land. The only way I see to do this is to either remove ghost acres altogether or make significant changes to the amount of ghost acres you get. In which case, you wouldn't have the guarantee of getting your land back.
In fact, I think the original point of having that guarantee is a silly reason to advocate for grabbing anyway. That's actually a better argument for land-trading among one's own countries, since I wouldn't have to waste turns spying targets, adjusting breaks, and checking news to make sure my clan hasn't farmed your clan....
Instead I can just login to two countries, have them hit each other 3 times, and move on.